I'm pretty sure that I shared the threesome story with you. Things started to get a little weird afterwards, and I had a weird feeling BEFORE it happened that might go down. From time to time Antonia would ask questions like "did her pussy feel better than mine?" Or "does she suck you better than I do?" Typical insecurity issues that I can understand. If I had watched some guy fucking her, I would be like that too! And, to be fair, I even asked her if she wanted to have two guys at the same time. Thankfully, for my sanity, she has no interest in that. Well - she had limited interest!
We were in bed and talking about things and the guy / guy / girl issue came up. She said that she honestly had never even thought of it, and would like some time to really give it some thought. She wanted to really imagine herself with two men, examine how she'd feel, etc. I told her to take all the time in the world. A couple of nights later the subject came back up and she said that she was torn. The thought of having two cocks to play with, or in her, was appealing "as hell." But the guy attached to the second cock was a real turn off. She said that the only gender that she would really want to share her bed with was another female and she wasn't wild about that anymore.
Well - wouldn't you know it - we have a vast variety of toys now. I started kissing Antonia's neck, which is a sure fire way to make sure I don't get a lot of sleep that night, and before I knew it my mouth was between her thighs. I had one of the larger dildos inside her as I slowly worked my tongue over her clit. I'd pull the dildo out, and tease her with the tip slowly, sliding the dildo half way in before quickly pulling it all the way out. It was driving her insane, I wouldn't apply direct pressure to her clit or fully fuck her with the dildo.
Suddenly I rolled her on her side with me behind her in a spooning fashion. Reaching around her, I slowly slid the dildo all the way in her. "You want two cocks?" I growled in her ear, pulling her head back by her hair. Antonia whimpered that she did, so I started to position my cock over her ass. "Baby, I'm not ready for that" she said "you haven't done anything there yet..." she whispered. I moaned in her ear to shut up and let "us" fuck her. Rubbing my cock between her thighs while I fucked her with the dildo, I got my cock wet enough to slowly start to work the head inside her ass.
Shortly I had both cocks deep inside her. I would pull mine out of her ass while thrusting the dildo in, and the other way. I kept moaning in her ear if she loved it. Antonia's hands were above her head and she was gripping the pillows so hard I think she was going to tear them. She was moving her hips to meet the thrusting of my own and getting louder and louder. Soon she had one hand between her legs and was viciously working on her clit with one hand and pulling her nipples really hard with the other.
I started to pound the dildo into her pussy at the same time as my cock in her ass and I knew I was going to last much longer. Good thing, just before I was going to cum she moaned that she couldn't take my cock in her ass much longer. Letting go of the dildo, I grabbed her hips and started fucking her ass very hard. Almost on cue she grabbed the dildo and started pounding that inside her pussy. My orgasm washed over me so hard I think my eyes would pop...although I didn't actually see the load of cum it felt like a gallon spurted into her.
We ended up taking the dildo into the shower with us and she gave me quite a show with it while I sat on the bench under the hot stream of water. Laying in bed later and talking she said it was amazing...but she's really glad that extra cock didn't come with extra hands.
...and so am I! Man, I'm selfish.