Sam moaned and rolled onto his back. I gently traced my fingers over Sam's balls while my other hand slid up and down his cock as I sucked it. I had a hard time putting much of it in my mouth, it was much larger than the cock I was used to sucking on. I ran the tip of my finger between Sam's ass and balls, which is something that I love. He jumped his hips a little, perhaps surprised that I was so aggressive and had an idea of what I was doing.
My mind was whirling as I sucked him. The thought of such a large cock in my ass excited and scared me, but the thought that I didn't know how to initiate that scared me more. I was more wild with desire than I had been in a long time, having someone completely new and naked under me was a powerful feeling.
Sam gently pushed me away and on to my back, lowered his mouth on my cock. The difference between his ability to suck on my cock was so much different, it's hard to explain. His mouth felt amazing and right off the bat I had to keep him from getting me off.
For what seemed half the night we traded back and forth, sucking each other. In between we would lie face to face, stroking each other slowly, not saying a word. I had my eyes closed when I felt his lips on mine. This was something at this point that I had close to no experience with, and wasn't sure how I felt about it. Our tongues danced over each other for a moment and he kissed his way to my cock again.
While he sucked me this his finger made their way to my ass, playing with my asshole and balls. He made everything so slippery and wet between my legs and I felt the pressure of his finger sliding inside me. Then the additional pressure of another finger. He slowly sucked me while fingering my ass. It hurt at first, as it always did, but I started to loosen. He stopped, which had been our cue that it was my time to suck him. I wanted something else.
I turned over, back to him, and reaching behind me took his cock into my hand, pulling him toward me. I felt him rubbing his cock head all over my ass hole and I guided him to my ass. He started putting pressure and I felt the tip of his head start to edge into me. It was such an explosion of pain that at first I almost told him to stop. He couldn't have had more than the very tip in, but his cock was so thick. Finally the whole head popped into my ass and I almost screamed. He asked me if I was okay and all I could say was go slow. I felt like I was out of breath and wanted to stop so badly.
He started moving his head inside me back and forth, slowly sliding more and more of his cock into me. After he got it to a certain point I realized that it didn't hurt anymore. He was so large that it wasn't completely comfortable, but it wasn't painful. His hand reached around me and started stroking my cock. I had to keep telling him that I would cum soon. He would stop. Sam had his hands on my hips, and his forehead on my back, slowly sliding his cock in and out of my ass. I was slowly stroking my own cock, loving the feeling of him inside me.
He started going a little faster and moaning a little. I asked if he was going to go and he just grunted, wrapping his arms around me and pumping into me so hard that it started to hurt again. I felt his cum spurt inside me as he came. Almost instantly I felt him going soft, still in my ass.
He pulled out and I rolled onto my back. I was a little bummed because I knew from prior experiences whoeever came first usually didn't want to do anything else. I was surprised when Sam took me back into his mouth. It took maybe 10 seconds and I was cumming in his mouth.
We never said a word to each other about it, but this wasn't the only time this happened. Many times in the summer I hear a tapping outside the window by my bed. In the dead of night he and I would sneak into the woods. Leaning against a tree he would pull my shorts down and suck me off. Sometimes he would get me off and not want anything in return. Other times he would take me into his arm, kissing me deeply, and I knew what he wanted. I would stand against a tree, arms holding me steady, as he slid into my ass and fucked me.
Basically we were each other's sex toys for that summer and I still think ahout it a lot to this day.